Dr. Peter Attia – Zero Fasting Live Q+A

Watch the video here

Key Takeaways

  • Peter’s fasting routine:
    • Time-restricted feeding 4-5 days a week
    • A 36-48 hour water-only fast once a month
    • A 5-7 day water-only fast once a quarter sandwiched by a week of following a ketogenic diet on each end
      • During the water-only fasts, Peter doesn’t consume coffee and tries to strength train every day
  • Whether or not coffee breaks the fast depends on why you’re fasting in the first place
    • Artificial sweeteners belong in the same bucket
  • When breaking a prolonged fast, eat something small/low volume, low in glucose, and preferably higher in monounsaturated fats (as opposed to saturated or polyunsaturated fats)
  • Strength training during a fast is very important as it helps to preserve muscle mass
  • “Don’t try to trade your health for wealth then buy your health back” 

Products & Supplements Mentioned

  • During Peter’s water-only fasts, he supplements with:
    • Jarrow’s Phosphatidylserine (typically 300 mg) (which also makes it easier to fall asleep)
    • Magnesium – he steers clear of magnesium oxide (as it tends to act as a laxative) and instead prefers something like SlowMag
    • L-threonate (it’s a magnesium transporter that allows it to get across the blood-brain-barrier more effectively)
      • Peter says it’s helped his sleep, whether he’s fasting or not
  • Despite various claims, citrus bergamot probably doesn’t enhance autophagy 
  • You can measure your ketone levels with a Precision Xtra 

Intro

  • This is a Q&A with Dr. Peter Attia (@PeterAttiaMD) in partnership with the fasting app, Zero
    • Peter is The Peter Attia Drive Podcast – check out the Podcast Notes
    • Check out the Podcast Notes from Peter’s first Q&A
    • Also, check out the Podcast Notes from the Zero Fasting Q&A with Dr. Rhonda Patrick

Peter’s Fasting Routine

  • Time-restricted feeding 4-5 days a week
  • A 36-48 hour water-only fast once a month
  • A 5-7 day water-only fast once a quarter sandwiched by a week of following a ketogenic diet on each end

Where are we in the cause/effect chain of understanding the relationship between obesity and insulin resistance?

  • “I feel less knowledgeable today than I did in 2013… My absolute knowledge has grown, but my relative knowledge has shrunk.”

How has fasting improved Peter’s life?

  • Perhaps the biggest benefit of all is psychological
    • Having a regular fasting practice makes it 10x easier to avoid eating if he only has access to junk food (i.e. on a long travel day)

Advice for Younger People | Increasing Healthspan and Lifespan

  • “Longevity is a compounding sport”
  • Remember: Slow and steady wins the race
    • The more consistent you can be with the way you sleep, eat, and exercise, the greater the benefit you’ll experience much later on
  • “Don’t try to trade your health for wealth then buy your health back” 

How do you know if intermittent fasting is effectively addressing insulin resistance?

  • The short definition of insulin resistance: the body requires more insulin to get glucose out of circulation into the muscle
    • Signs include elevated levels of insulin and/or elevated levels of glucose following the ingestion of glucose
  • Average blood glucose and the standard deviation of blood glucose levels are good proxies for glucose disposal capability
    • Thus, you’d want to look for an improvement in these two numbers

Does coffee break a fast?

  • It depends why you’re fasting in the first place
    • If your fasting to lose weight…
      • No 
    • If you’re fasting to improve metabolic parameters often accompanied by weight loss (reductions in glucose/insulin)…
      • No
    • If you’re fasting to reduce inflammation…
      • No
    • If you’re fasting for gut rest…
      • Yes
    • If you’re fasting to increase autophagy (the process by which dysfunctional cells digest themselves)…
      • We don’t know the answer because we can’t measure autophagy in humans (yet)
      • During Peter’s water-only fasts, he chooses not to consume coffee – “But I don’t know definitively that I should not be consuming coffee. My intuition is the less I’m consuming, the better.”
  • In summary – “I don’t know the answer to this question and I don’t know anyone who does”

What about non-nutritive sweeteners like aspartame, saccharine, and sucralose?

  • “I think they probably belong in the same camp as coffee”

Major in the Major, Minor in the Minor

  • If you’re already fasting, you’re getting 97% of the benefit
    • Don’t worry about the 1-3% difference you’d obtain in your physiology by avoiding coffee/artificial sweeteners during a fast

More on Measuring Autophagy

  • As mentioned, it’s not currently measurable in humans
  • Ideally, in the future, we’d be able to look at a series of biomarkers and determine the extent to which you’re undergoing autophagy
    • We know what happens when we fast, so we’re not too far off:
      • Glucose decreases
      • Insulin decreases
      • Free fatty acids decrease
      • Some amino acids drop to 0 (like methionine)
      • Some amino acids drop and plateau (like leucine)
      • Uric acid increases
    • “My suspicion is that there are ~25 different biomarkers out there that would then get layered into an algorithm to give someone an autophagy meter if you will”

Sleep Supplements During a Fast

  • Many report trouble sleeping during a prolonged water-only fast
    • This isn’t solely due to hunger, but perhaps more so due to higher cortisol levels
      • There’s an evolutionary reason for this – our ancestors probably treated periods without access to food as a state of hyper-alarm 
  • During Peter’s water-only fasts, he supplements with:
  • Note – be careful with long-term melatonin supplementation (it downregulates your melatonin receptors)
    • And as a general rule, only use sleep supplements when you need them (i.e. to fight jet lag)

What else does Peter supplement with during a water-only fast?

  • Magnesium
    • In general, most people are magnesium deficient
    • Magnesium also tends to get depleted during a fast (or with general carbohydrate restriction)
    • Peter supplements with magnesium every day, but when fasting does so at a much higher level 
      • During a fast, he’ll stay clear of magnesium oxide as it tends to act as a laxative and instead prefers something like SlowMag
  • L-threonate (it’s a magnesium transporter that allows it to get across the blood-brain-barrier more effectively)
    • Peter says it’s helped his sleep, whether he’s fasting or not

What should you eat when breaking a prolonged water-only fast?

  • From a physiologic perspective, meals low in glucose will produce less of a glycemic spike (which you want to avoid)
  • Eat something small/low volume
    • Why? – During a long fast, your stomach contracts 
  • Eat something nutritious – you’re looking to refeed the cells that survived the fast and you want to provide them with the best nutrients possible
  • Eat monounsaturated fats as opposed to saturated fats which, especially if shorter chain, can lead to a very upset stomach
    • Also, avoid omega-6, polyunsaturated fats as well which are junky anyway

Should you exercise during a prolonged water-only fast?

  • Peter recalls a study:
    • Two groups of men were calorically restricted by 50%
    • Both groups were “exercised like crazy” (similar to ~2 hours of very intense exercise or ~3 hours of modest exercise)
    • Men that received testosterone supplementation gained muscle mass
      • The other group failed to lose muscle mass
  • Exercise is VERY important during a fast
    • For one, exercise should always be a part of a healthy day
    • Exercise seems to augment/amplify autophagy
    • Strength training preserves muscle mass
      • During a fast, mTOR activity is downregulated – strength training during a fast transiently activates mTOR (you’re sort of getting the best of both worlds)
  • On the cardio side, pick and choose your battles
    • Repeated bouts of extremely high-intensity exercise (like with a Tabata) are very difficult during a fast as your glycogen levels are depleted
      • For this reason, this type of exercise is off the table for Peter during a fast
    • A step just below the above in intensity (like the pace a runner or cyclist would use during a race) also becomes difficult during a water-only fast (Peter estimates even well-conditioned athletes are ~50%, if not more, dependent on glycogen during this phase of exercise)
      • This is known as the “functional threshold power” state
      • Peter doesn’t do much of this type of cardio, fasting or not – he much prefers shorter bouts of ultra-high power output or longer battles with zone 2 cardio (below)
    • Below the above, we have zone 2 cardio
      • Zone 2 is the highest level of output at which you can carry out a conversation (more accurately, your lactate levels must be < 2 mmol)
      • Peter typically does four zone 2 workouts a week
      • Zone 2 cardio is completely doable in the fasted state, but Peter much prefers to replace his typical zone 2 workouts with strength training sessions (he tries to lift every day during his fast)
  • The takeaways:
    • Er on the side of lifting more than doing cardio during a fast
    • If you do cardio, adjust your expectations in regards to your capacity to produce glycolytic power
    • Also, adjust your expectations when lifting
      • Strength typically doesn’t diminish during a fast, but your stamina and recovery time between sets will
    • Adjust your expectations in general:
      • “When I’m fasting, I’m only in the gym for about an hour as opposed to my normal 90 minutes”
    • In a sense, strength train during a fast only for as a physiologic stimulus for mTOR

Peter’s Workout Routine

  • Lift – Monday, Wednesday, and Friday
  • Zone 2 cardio – Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday, and Sunday
  • Tabata workouts on his Peleton – sprinkled throughout

Fasting for Women

  • “I would say, based on my clinical experience, in general, it’s harder for women to fast than men. I don’t know why that is.”
    • Perhaps there’s an evolutionary reason – it’s much more difficult for women to ovulate or lactate while fasting
  • “For women who are trying to get pregnant, I don’t think fasting, I don’t think ketogenic diets, I don’t think anything that signals energy reduction makes sense”

Hot/Cold Therapy During a Prolonged Fast

  • “Few things feel better than a sauna during a water-only fast”
    • Why? – During a prolonged fast, people experience hypothyroidism 
      • Thus metabolism slows and you walk around at a lower body temperature (this is why Peter loves fasting during the summer)
  • Cold therapy tends to increases norepinephrine in the brain which enhances mood
    • There’s no reason you can’t take a cold shower or bath during a fast

Are there long-term negative effects on metabolism if you time-restrict your eating daily?

  • “I don’t think we know the answer yet”
  • As a precaution, Peter only time-restricts his eating 4-5 days a week
    • He recommends his patients do the same (and on the days they don’t time-restrict, he advises them to focus more on what they eat)
  • Peter spent 6 months in 2014 doing eating only 1 meal per day and didn’t notice any negative consequences

Fasting with Hashimoto’s Disease

  • Hashimoto’s is a form of hypothyroidism 
  • Peter’s advice – 100% speak with your endocrinologist or whoever’s managing your hormone medication before fasting

Does citrus bergamot activate autophagy?

  • Some people say it does
    • “I have never seen a credible piece of evidence to suggest that it could in any way, shape, or form increase autophagy”
  • It does have some efficacy at lowing cholesterol – “Though I’m not a fan at using it at all”
  • “I’m not a fan of this supplement in any way, shape, or form”

Are there benefits to fasting even if you don’t enter ketosis?

  • Definitely yes
  • Ketosis = having a blood ketone level of 0.5 mmol or greater
    • If you’re frequently eating carbs, your ketone levels are 0 mmol
    • When most people wake up in the morning, their blood ketone levels are ~0.1 – 0.2 mmol
    • During a prolonged water-only fast, you’ll enter starvation ketosis with a ketone level of 4-7 mmol
  • You can measure your ketone levels with a Precision Xtra 
  • At the end of the day – “It’s a huge mistake to turn fasting into a ketone contest. The idea that the success or failure of your fast is predicated on how high your ketone levels get is total nonsense.”

Additional Notes

  • Peter wears a Dexcom G6 continuous glucose monitor
  • Peter much prefers glass-bottled Topo Chico to plastic-bottled Topo Chico
  • Peter uses both the Lactate Plus and the Lactate Pro to measure his lactate levels during and after doing zone 2 cardio
Zero Fasting Q&As : , , , , , , , , , , ,
Notes By MMiller

More Notes on these topics

Top Insights and Tactics

Don't Miss Out on the Best Ideas From the World's Best Podcasts

Get Healthier, Wealthier and Happier in Just 5 Minutes with the Podcast Notes newsletter

No Thanks