Startalk: Edward Snowden (Part 2)

8/10 Microphones, Listen HERE @neiltyson

  • It was Neil Tyson’s idea to have Snowden join Twitter as @Snowden (already over 1 million followers in 24 hours)!!
  • What Snowden revealed in partnership with the Free Press was unlawful behavior that courts have agreed with him on
    • Nobody in the US is above the law, including the NSA
    • Even the President didn’t know the full details of this program
  • Application of force must be necessary and proportionate to a threat (same reason by we don’t launch nukes right away)
  • NSA has offensive and defensive goals, but since 9/11 it has shifted from National Security to National SURVEILLENCE
    • They are weakening the security of all our systems to help their offense (by ruining all of our defense)
    • We have more informational valuable assets (e.g. tech secrets, fingerprints of CIA spies, etc.) in the USA than other countries, as a result we have more to lose by being hacked (e.g. by China) vs. what we can gain from hacking others
      • Thus by weakening all IT security we lose more than others like China gain
    • Surveillance Now vs. Cold War
      • During Cold War we had someone to compare ourselves – we saw the aggressive nature of the Soviets as confirmation of our moral superiority and we turned away from them (but couldn’t have easily done the same)
      • Now our the bar (“competitive honesty” is so low from ISIS/Al Queda that we’ve allowed ourselves to lower the bar on personal freedom in a way we did not in the past
    • New technologies is cause to worry even more, not less – Metadata is in many ways worse than listening to your phone call
      • MetaData (data about data): who you are calling, when, where you were, etc. (context of a communication)
      • Mass Metadata is more valuable than content as there is too much content to listen to/analyze en masse, BUT
        • Metadata is very easy to be analyzed by computers
        • This is well established even amount defenders of the surveillance state: Have actually said that with enough metadata, you don’t need content data
        • Keith Alexander: We kill people based off of metadata, we drone strike cell phones (“signature strikes”), not people (which is why we kill the wrong people all the time)
        • Medadata is the type of info a private investigator would collect about you:
          • Who you are meeting, where, how long, where you go later, where you live, what car you drive, etc. = Pattern of Life
        • Encryption:
          • Symmetric encryption: Same key that works on both sides (lock/unlock)
          • Asymmetric encryption: One key to lock and another to unlock (allow to share knowledge with people without sharing the key/password
          • Secret Sharing Schemes:
            • How can you enable 5 or more people to see info, while making sure that one can’t ruin it (may need n/5 to sign in at the same time
            • Additional constraints: location, altitude, time of day, number of people and multifactor authentication (e.g. password plus pin code from SMS)
          • Preference is to send an encrypted message that doesn’t even look like a message
            • How do you divorce the content from the fact that the communication was sent to begin with (try route through a ton of volunteers who send the info through one another (e.g. TOR)
          • Hardest part of encryption is generating truly random numbers, end up with pseudo-random numbers
          • Signal and Noise: Is the noise in universe actual noise? There are signals you’re uninterested in because they interfere with a signal you are interested in there, but it’s still a signal, not noise
            • By listening closely to what you want, you get other signals at the same time
            • Just like mass surveillance: So much noise that they’re actually unable to actually stop even 1 terrorist act
            • Worse, all the resources devoted to it are taking away resources from other traditional law enforcement activities
            • We are creating a haystack of human lives that hides the needles
          • Rather than watch people that haven’t done something wrong, we used to watch those who have = Probable Cause
            • Then you can tap just their phones, etc.
          • At least at airports it is limited to just that time/place, not everything in your life

Sponsors:,, Macwelden,

StarTalk :
Notes By Mr. Podcast Notes

More Notes on these topics

Top Insights and Tactics From

31 Best Podcasts of All Time

FREE when you join over 35,000 subscribers to the
Podcast Notes newsletter

No Thanks